CLOSE
Loading...
12° Nicosia,
22 November, 2026
 
Home  /  News

Erdogan tells Guterres yes to five-party Cyprus talks, but insists on two states

A Foreign Ministry document seen by Kathimerini reveals the “good news and bad news” the U.N. chief relayed to President Christodoulides.

Pavlos Xanthoulis

Pavlos Xanthoulis

Two months ago, in late September, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan formally told U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres that he was ready for another five-party meeting on Cyprus. He also made Ankara’s red lines clear, insisting on a settlement based on “two separate states” on the island. Kathimerini understands that Guterres heard Erdogan’s position directly from the Turkish president and formally briefed both Brussels and Cypriot President Nikos Christodoulides. Since Sept. 24, Christodoulides has known from the U.N. chief himself that Erdogan remains committed to a settlement based on two separate entities in Cyprus.

According to an internal document from the Republic of Cyprus’ Foreign Ministry seen by Kathimerini, Guterres told Christodoulides at their meeting that he had “good news and bad news.” Ankara was willing to attend a five-party conference, but it was sticking to its position on two separate states. In effect, the bad news canceled out the supposed good news. The United Nations and the European Union know where Ankara stands, as does Nicosia, which received a detailed briefing on Turkey’s position on Sept. 24.

Antonio Guterres gave President Christodoulides “good news and bad news” on Sept. 24. Erdogan was ready for another five-party conference, but his goal remained two separate states in Cyprus.

Even so, Christodoulides continues to hold out hope that another five-party conference will lead to direct talks on a Cyprus settlement. Guterres’ formal briefing gave little grounds for that expectation. The bad news he delivered to Nicosia was that Erdogan was standing firm on two separate states.

Ankara and the U.N. Secretariat promptly relayed both pieces of news to Brussels. An EU source familiar with the discussions told Kathimerini that “the EU is guarded and, under the present circumstances, sees meaningful progress on Cyprus as extremely difficult.” The source, who spoke on condition of anonymity, added that “a five-party conference will only make sense if it leads to a new round of direct talks. For those talks to have a chance of succeeding, both sides need to be on the same page, and clearly, and unfortunately, I would say, they aren’t right now.”

At the same Sept. 24 meeting, the outgoing U.N. chief told Christodoulides that the EU planned to sound out Ankara again in the coming weeks as part of its dealings with Turkey. Several earlier appeals and overtures had led nowhere, but Guterres spoke of “one more effort.” Christodoulides told him he had put proposals to European Commission Executive Vice President Raffaele Fitto. As this article was being written, Fitto was expected to meet Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan, who 24 hours earlier had made a point of declaring that “there are two separate peoples, two democracies and two states on the island” of Cyprus.

Whatever comes of Fitto’s mission, the extent to which Nicosia has already backed down in an effort to draw Turkey in through the EU deserves attention. The Christodoulides government initially linked progress on EU-Turkey issues to a Cyprus settlement based on U.N. Security Council resolutions. It later changed its tune, speaking more generally of “developments on the Cyprus issue.” In light of Guterres’ briefing to Christodoulides, Nicosia’s position shifted further. Its efforts now center on getting direct talks restarted in exchange for progress on EU-Turkey issues, with no guarantee about the basis for a possible new U.N.-led process and, more importantly, no guarantee about its outcome.

Christodoulides is holding out progress on EU-Turkey issues, particularly an upgrade of Turkey’s customs union with the EU, which Brussels and Ankara are already discussing and pursuing, simply to get direct talks underway again. He is seeking no commitment on the framework for those talks or requiring a positive outcome. The “bad news” Guterres relayed to Christodoulides on Sept. 24 and to Brussels casts a shadow over the prospects for a Cyprus settlement under the U.N.’s “agreed framework.” A bizonal, bicommunal federation is increasingly in danger of becoming an empty slogan.

What is the president trying to achieve?

Given the news Guterres brought from Erdogan about his insistence on two separate states, it is fair to ask what Christodoulides hopes to achieve. The Cyprus president continues to keep expectations alive ahead of the outgoing U.N. chief’s upcoming three-way meeting with the leaders of the two communities and a possible new five-party conference that would also bring in the guarantor powers.

The prospects for a settlement appear bleak. Erdogan is pursuing a solution based on two separate entities, while Nicosia continues to call for a bizonal, bicommunal federation.

“So if Cyprus talks were to begin under these conditions, it would be highly unlikely that the two sides could bridge their diametrically opposed positions,” a well-informed EU source said. “That is an assessment shared by the EU and the U.N.”

Given how bleak the prospects are, the only purpose a new process might serve is to put on a show of negotiations that could be put to use in the campaign for the 2028 presidential election. That seems to be what Christodoulides is banking on.

How Nicosia backed down and what it is offering Ankara

The Christodoulides government had maintained that it had secured a link between progress on EU-Turkey issues and a Cyprus settlement. It explicitly cited both the agreed framework for a bizonal, bicommunal federation and the point where talks broke off at Crans-Montana in 2017. Christodoulides himself repeatedly pointed to the European Council conclusions of April 18, 2024, as proof that this link had been secured. Nicosia later began referring on several occasions to a link between EU-Turkey issues and “developments on the Cyprus issue,” sidestepping any reference to a settlement itself.

Once Erdogan made clear to Guterres that he was sticking to two separate states, and Guterres passed that bad news on to Brussels and Christodoulides, Nicosia adjusted both its language and its objective.

The Christodoulides government now appears ready, with help from Brussels, to back progress on EU-Turkey issues, particularly an upgrade of Turkey’s customs union with the EU. The only thing it is asking in return is for the Turkish side to come back to the table for a new round of direct talks on Cyprus.

In other words, Nicosia is prepared to help hand Ankara gifts without making a settlement or the framework for reaching one, a condition. Its sole condition is that the Turkish side return to the table, whatever position Ankara takes once it gets there and however events unfold. The bad news Erdogan delivered to Guterres suggests the outlook is particularly grim.

What stands out is how far Nicosia is watering down its position, offering concessions on EU-Turkey issues simply to get negotiations started again, while the Turkish side is setting terms tied to the outcome it wants, in line with Erdogan’s “bad news.” Ankara and Tufan Erhurman are demanding an upfront commitment from Nicosia and the international community to “direct trade” with and “direct flights” from the “TRNC,” whatever the outcome of any new talks. That would give the breakaway entity a way to establish “direct relations” with the international community.

In doing so, they are also making use of what the outgoing U.N. chief formally introduced as a “methodology filter,” asking the two sides to decide the rules of the game for any new negotiations.

TAGS
Cyprus  |  Turkey

News: Latest Articles

Joining the Schengen Area would be a major achievement for the government on several fronts and, if completed, would stand out as one of the milestones of its five-year term.

Are we ready for Schengen?

Cyprus may be close to meeting the requirements for joining Schengen. It also needs to prepare for what happens once it ...
Michalis Persianis
 |  NEWS
EU Commission hacked

EU Commission hacked

Most staff systems are back online after more than 10 days of disruption, but investigators are still checking whether employees’ ...
Newsroom
 |  NEWS
X