CLOSE
Loading...
12° Nicosia,
01 December, 2022
 

Language and political nonsense

In Greece the simplification of language can reach levels of absurdity

Nikos Konstandaras

Nikos Konstandaras

In his famous essay “Politics and the English Language,” George Orwell argued that the use of simple language – free of pretension, foreign words and vagueness – would improve the level of political thought.

Since then, almost anyone writing on the relationship between language and politics has referred to the 1946 essay, whether agreeing or disagreeing with it.

In Greece, however, we see that the simplification of language can reach such levels of absurdity as to make a mockery of this theory – of the very issue of political thought and debate.

From twitter troll orgies to some announcements from the prime minister’s press office (but also in too many “speeches” in Parliament), we are witness to language that has sunk to such depths of vileness and aggression that we must conclude that those who debase language in this way either have no wish to take part in any political debate or know no other way of talking.

"When you make a stupid remark its stupidity will be obvious, even to yourself”

Although both arguments may be valid, in the case of the prime minister’s press office, we must suspect that the second possibility is more likely.

Because even if we accept that the frequent, adolescent attacks on political rivals are a tactical device – an effort to marshal the troops of the government camp – we cannot say the same about the level of the verbal clash with Turkey.

Even as the prime minister appears to wish to stay coolheaded, his press office has at times taken Ankara’s bait and got caught up in a slanging match. (Unless we believe that there is some great plan whereby the government is playing the tough guy so as to keep anyone else from taking the low road.)

Personal attacks

The vicious and personal level of political debate confirms a desire for confrontation, a rejection of any possibility of consensus and cooperation with rivals.

It reveals either overweening confidence in victory or fatalism – when the desire for no-holds-barred conflict reveals the hope that in the turmoil there will be neither winners nor losers.

The result is division and stagnation. Orwell noted that when simple language is used, “when you make a stupid remark its stupidity will be obvious, even to yourself.”

The implication is that the speaker will want to avoid looking stupid.

If we accept Noam Chomsky’s idea that language is not so much a tool for communicating but for thinking and interpreting thought, then we ought to be even more worried – seeing people in official positions proud of the nonsense they spout.

 

TAGS
Greece  |  Politics  |  language  |  debate

Comment: Latest Articles

[AP]

Merchants of Death

Human traffickers could soon outnumber drug traffickers in the country’s (Greece's) prisons
Opinion
 |  OPINION
'Woman, life, freedom!’

'Woman, life, freedom!’

'Isn’t there an obvious contradiction that a country claiming to be a democracy has a special police force tasked with carrying ...
Opinion
 |  OPINION
The embargo has its own history

The embargo has its own history

'It is outrageous that US support for the illegal Turkish military occupation continues while the embargo on the victim ...
Opinion
 |  OPINION
Photo courtesy Unsplash

Winter, Putin's ally

Twice in the history of Europe, two Great Powers on the continent attempted to crush Russia, but winter saved her
Opinion
 |  OPINION
Penalizing Russia

Penalizing Russia

The solidarity shown by the entire EU with regards to penalizing Russia inevitably has limitations.
Opinion
 |  OPINION
Members of feminist organizations hold placards outside the Athens Court of Appeals on February 14, 2022, during the trial over the murder of student Eleni Topaloudi by two men on Rhodes in 2018.

Femicide and punishment

A life sentence cannot really mean for life, but it cannot mean 16 years in jail for certain heinous criminal behaviors ...
Opinion
 |  OPINION
Solving Cyprus

Solving Cyprus

A solution to the Cyprus issue will go a long way toward facilitating Ankara’s goal of playing an important role in the ...
Athanasios Ellis
 |  OPINION
X